I wrote all of the lyrics and was the executive producer (read: I covered all costs) on the project. Luke Conard was the vocalist and handled most of the actual production right up to the end, when drummer Christian Caldeira stepped in to help. Jason Munday played guitars and wrote the music to four of the songs. Raven Zoe wrote the music to four songs as well, while Ted Hu played piano and composed the music for one song.
Then there were the additional vocalists, the saxophone player, the cover artist, the DVD authoring guy, etc etc. It took all of us working under my, and Luke’s, direction to bring this project to light. Erase This would not be what it is today without any one of us.
I starting writing the first song in August of 2009. I started with a rough idea of a couple stuck in a relationship out of habit, not desire, and decided to figure out the story backwards from there.
My debut EP, Taking Leave, was a very linear concept piece; there was a beginning, a middle and an end, with a story arc, told within the lyrics. Erase This is less linear, but also tells a story.
Before reading on, I encourage you to listen to the album first, all the way through, as it was meant to be played. The following discussions are only my interpretations of the songs. You are free to, and encouraged to, draw your own interpretations based on your own experiences. Good lyrics draw you in and flip switches in your mind. They’re specific enough to leave a mark, but general enough that they can be applied to your own past and present just as easily as mine. If after listening to the album you want another interpretation of the lyrics, then please, read on.
“Making A Scene” is the blissful high point of our couple’s relationship. Dancing in empty parking lots, driving together with the radio loud, the destination unknown. Just being together is enough, and our male lead finally feels he’s living the dream, acting out his movie script ending. The sax solo was performed by Robert Kyle, the brother-in-law of the drummer in my first band from when I was fifteen years old.
“Shortwave, Part 1” is the first hint of any dissatisfaction as the narrator (it’s not revealed whether it’s the male or female character) begs for the daily, repeated static to end, and for their partner to simply talk to them, to simply say ‘hello’. The radio DJ heard in excerpts here and in interludes throughout the album is Hollywood film star Kevin Pollak.
“All I Am” flashes forward to after the relationship has clearly ended and our male lead sits alone, rereading letters from his ex-girlfriend. He’s not sure how all the fragmented pieces of memories should fit together, but he cherishes each and every piece. “All I Am” was the last song recorded for the album, and was inspired, lyrically, by Tori Amos’ “Tear In Your Hand”, which also tells a story of the aftermath of a break-up.
“Mirror Song” continues “All I Am”’s scene as our male lead comes across a few photos of him and his ex together. He has forgotten how happy they once looked together, and begins to understand that maybe he never really heard her voice until now, after she was gone. “Mirror Song” was originally recorded by Tom Milsom and Kristina Horner for my debut EP. Kristina reprises her vocal role here.
“Turn Signal” uses the metaphor of running away to illustrate our female lead’s desire to leave the relationship. Even if she just retreats in her mind, not the physical world, the result is the same. “Turn Signal” sets the stage for the leading single from the album, “Boxcar Blood”.
“Boxcar Blood” tells the story of our young couple attempting to run away together. But our male lead can’t really commit to ‘the plan’ like his girlfriend can. In the music video for “Boxcar Blood”, our male lead can’t catch the train as it’s pulling away with his girlfriend on board. This displays another non-literal example of her leaving and the situation being out of his control.
“Winter’s Song” was released as a digital single back in December of 2009, six months before Erase This was released. In “Winter’s Song”, our male lead attempts to express how he feels about his girlfriend through song, but she doesn’t hear him; she’s in her own world, singing her own ending.
“Shortwave, Part 2” uses the metaphor again of singing to express feeling, only this time our female lead has finally found her ‘voice’. For the first time, what she wants to say and how she feels comes easy to her. She sings it out loud for everyone to hear. The vocal chorus at the end features Kristina Horner, Rebecca Brickley and Caitlin Rielly with Luke Conard and Christian Caldeira.
“Forgiven” is an updated recording from my previous EP, performed by my new band. While the song isn’t directly a part of the storyline, I believe we all have times in our life when we need someone to understand, empathize, and tell us they’re there for us or forgive us for whatever mistakes we’ve made. Maybe our female lead wants to be forgiven for stringing her boyfriend along for so long. Maybe our male lead wants to find his place or calling, now that he’s lost without his partner. As stated earlier, ultimately, it’s up to you as the listener.
“Erase This” was the first song written for the album, but ended up being the last track. In a desperate attempt at reminding the woman he still has feelings for that, at one time, she shared those feelings, our male lead sends fallen autumn leaves for her to burn in her back yard. The one smell she loves so much. The one smell that instantly reminds him of her. The one smell that brings many of us home.
Not included on the album, but important nonetheless is “Summer of ’09”, the digital single I released with ALL CAPS. “Summer of ’09” was originally written for Erase This, which some of you have figured out as its lyrics fit in perfectly with the storyline and overall theme of the album. But I didn’t think it brought anything new to the table and once the melody was written, I didn’t think it fit in with the rest of this batch of songs. So I cut it and gave it to Luke’s pop band, ALL CAPS, for their album Bmin/E.
So, there it is. “That’s all?” you say? Well, the “Complete” in this article’s title refers to the Idiot, not the Guide, so, no, this isn’t all of it, this is just to get you started. There is a lot for you to discover on your own through repeated listens to the album, if you care to (and I really hope you care to).
I am extremely proud of Erase This. I hope you find one, or many, songs here to connect with. One song to tell you you’re not alone in feeling however you feel. One song to smile with in some inside joke that I’ll never get, because now it’s between you, whatever switch I flipped in your mind, and the song. And maybe one song to just rock out to, even if you don’t analyze it within the context of the album as a whole.
If you’d like to share your review, or your own interpretations of these songs below, I’ll leave the comments section open, and will be here to discuss all of the above with you. If you don’t yet own Erase This, you can purchase a copy here: http://erasethis.com






{ 11 comments… read them below or add one }
Wow Alan. I have been listening to Erase This just about every day since I ordered it and downloaded it, but I had only picked up on half of these things, Alan you obviously never FTBA, this is such an amazingly crafted album.
I am so infinitely proud of you and everyone else involved. You’ve produced a wonderful piece of art that, from what I’ve seen in terms of reviews, many many people are enjoying. I’m still in awe at watching the whole process unfold, from writing lyrics to recording bass tracks to hearing talks between you and Luke about what comes next. I’m so pleased with the finished product, and I’m so glad you were finally able to create the album you heard in your head. <3
I just have to say that Winter’s Song is my favorite. “But you turn down the one song I wrote for you.” And the chorus are my favorite. But I love the whole thing! Musically, lyrically, I love it. And the cover included is beautiful as well.
And for the record, I still love Can’t.
Amazing. Just amazing! Like so many other people, this album has been on repeat since I pre-ordered and downloaded it. Amazing!! :D
I never picked up on a lot of these things, but now I think I can understand more….Erase This is simply beautiful. I can’t get enough of it, can’t wait for it to come in the mail.
DFTBA, Alan, even though I know you never do.
Thanks for this post! I bought this album as soon as it hit iTunes and have listened to it several times. You’re an outstanding lyricist, and I enjoyed reading about the story you were telling with each piece. Early impressions/thoughts. since you’re asking:
Maybe because it’s a duet, or maybe because of the underlying tenderness in the words, but the Mirror Song flips a hopeful switch in my mind. Something about it tells me that the story doesn’t have to be over. Also, it’s just stunningly beautiful.
All I Am, while obviously about a relationship, gives me a sense of being about life in general in that none of us can quite look back on our own story and see a perfect fit among all the pieces, a unified whole, yet all of the pieces matter.
Boxcar Blood is just an all-around fantastic piece. I haven’t figured out why I like it so much–just that lyric, vocals, instrumentation all work together for a really listenable and moving song.
Great call on picking Luke Conard for the vocals (besides voice and songs being a good match, it was him singing the chorus to Boxcar Blood on one of his vlogs that directed me to the album in the first place.) As a wrocker, it is a lot of fun for me to see so many of those whose music I’ve loved inside the HP community involved in work outside of it–Kristina, Christian, and Jason as well as Luke. Congratulations to everyone who participated for making an album to which I’m loving listening and re-listening. :)
…Wow.
Alan, if I ever craft a record that’s half as complex, thoughtful, catchy, awesome and straight-up rockin’ as Erase This, I will be very proud indeed.
I picked up on most of the things you talked about here – the non-linear story of the relationship, the drifting apart, interpretations of some songs in particular – but with a few differences. I somehow got the impression (which I still can’t shake) that there was another girl involved too. I got this vibe on All I Am and Winter’s Song; in All I Am, I thought the guy might be saying that he was growing increasingly disappointed and disillusioned with the relationship, so maybe he should seek elsewhere; Winter’s Song I imagined was addressed to the other girl, though I can’t put my finger on exactly why I thought this.
Bravo, sir. Between Taking Leave and Erase This, you’ve become one of my favourite musicians of all time.
- Dan
(P.S. My favourite tracks were Making A Scene, All I Am, Boxcar Blood and Shortwave, Pt. 2.
I love the album, just received it and it’s the first DFTBA record I’ve bought. It looks great, sounds great and I even got the little comic that comes with it.
Overall the lyrics are beautiful, the singing is shaky in parts but good and the music is fantastic though I much prefered the original version of Winter’s Song where the beautiful piano solo played a bigger part. Boxcar Blood is really great and all the songs that kinda stayed in the background upon my first listening have really grown on me since I’ve listened to it again.
The ‘experience’ of the album is really enhanced by the Radio DJ which pieces the songs together very nicely and gives a great flow and atmosphere to the album. I love the Digital Booklet we were sent too but wish it could have been printed as the artwork is stunning. The story was the only real weak point of the album if you ask me, it didn’t continue through the songs as I expected, probably because the narrative isn’t chronological. A lot of wild speculation is involved in piecing a story together which is why I came to see the guide. It seems like a story has been conjured up to find some kind of link between them instead of the songs being written for the story.
However the album is definitely one of my favourites and I just keep replaying it. I love the collaborative nature of the project and look forward to future DFTBA purchases!
Still can’t figure out where to put this DFTBA RECORDS sticker though…
I love Erase This, I bought it about a week ago off of iTunes. My favorite songs are Mirror Song and Boxcar Blood. The music is amazing, and so are the lyrics. I hope you do something like this again because I love this album a lot.
I love that the album is a story. A lot of albums aren’t, and I think that when they are, it brings a lot more life and emotion into each song.
Also, I want to know if you could get me the sheet music to Mirror Song, because it would be nice if I could learn to play it on the piano.
Great job everyone who worked on Erase This!
Hi- I really love Boxcar Blood.
The song and the video are both
great. In my opinion, it has the
ring of a “number one” song with
universal appeal. But what do I
know, I’m just a 51 year old
woman. You have crossed the
demographic barrier! I bought your
album also. By the way, my
daughter’s best friend looks like
a younger, female version of Luke
Conard. It’s pretty funny!
Mirror song is awesome. Its my boyfriend and i’s song. hes leaving for the army in a month. I really want to learn how to play it on piano for him before he leaves as a suprise. Ive looked all over google an youtube for chords. I cant find any. I found guitar ones but they didnt sound right. If you or someone could give me or tell me how to play it, i would be so grateful. Just email tham to me if anyone finds any.